There have been a number of blow-ups around indie authors with debatable attitudes just in the last 18 months, since I got online and discovered this massive community of writers I hadn’t even known existed. People talk about how authors should be humble and respectful, that readers would rather read the work of an author they actually like, and they’re right. But where do you draw the line?
I’m wondering about this because I think I’m on the wrong side of that line. I worry far too much about what other people think of me. I want them to like me. I know this is a hangover from growing up in boarding school. If you’re not liked in boarding school, your life is, well, difficult, to say the least.
I wasn’t liked.
(I swear I wasn’t a bad person – seriously, how bad can you be at the age of six?)
So these days I find myself terrified people won’t like me. I think there is some vague shadowy fear that if they don’t, they’ll put spiders in my bed. Whatever the reason, I worry. And it’s ridiculous, because no one can be liked by everyone. There will always be people who just don’t like you. Whether you get on fine with someone and then one day say something that resonates the wrong way with them, or there’s just no chemistry in the first place – that click that sparks a friendship, someone, somewhere, is going to decide one day that, no, you just don’t float their boat.
I have friends who like me, of course. Very close friends who think I’m wonderful. They like me in spite of my occasional obnoxiousness, which is nice, because sometimes I just get arsey for little to no reason at all. I try to keep myself offline at those times, but I don’t always succeed. Whatever. I’m human. Sometimes life gets a bit too much.
But then I see these published authors doing their published author thing, some of them wickedly famous, some of them writing full-time, some of them just friendly with people who are wickedly famous and/or writing full-time and I think, I want to be one of them. I want to be part of that group. I want them to like me.
Why?
Why am I wasting my time?
Make no mistake, I am wasting my time. If some industry big shot likes me and I write a great book, they’ll tell the world about it. If they don’t know me at all and I write a great book, they’ll tell the world about it anyway. And so will the littler shots. I’ve always despised the “It’s not what you know, it’s who you know” maxim, and yet I find myself turning into something of a snob. Will big shots liking you make you write better? Doubtful.
Because that’s what it comes down to, in the end. Your writing. And that doesn’t depend on who likes you or not. It’s yours. It is, to a certain extent, you. Part of who you are goes down on every page and those parts are you regardless of whether the reader likes you or not.
Now, to be clear, I’m categorically not saying that declaring oneself King of the World and all your works on a par with the Bible (of the World) is the way to go here.
What I am saying is that I ride a knife-edge of self-doubt (and I’m not alone here - Jennifer Williams wrote a brilliant post about this just the other day), but I’m on the wrong side of the edge. I need to stop worrying about what other people will think of me. What’s far more relevant is what they’ll think of what I write, but I’ll never find out if I don’t write it. Their possible future opinions have no meaning in the here and now. There’ll be time enough to worry about that once the story is completed and I start actually showing it to people. As a writer, as a teller of stories, I have a duty to myself, to my art, to tell my story, my way. The story must be told. It will be edited many times, and after the first time or two those edits will be based on other people’s feedback, but that initial story, its bones and muscles and internal organs, can only be laid down by me.
There is a time for self-doubt. It’s after you’ve written the story. Humility, too, as you have to be willing to accept feedback that may not jibe with your thoughts about what you’ve created. It’s part of the job.
But there is never a time for worrying about whether other people will like you or not. They will or they won’t. You can and should be respectful, but you can do that without being overly humble. Too much humility will have you believing you’re not worthy of talking to other people at all, and then they’ll never discover whether they like you or not, will they?
More importantly, it might make you decide you’re simply not capable of writing anything worth reading, and that could be the greatest tragedy of all. You should never let anyone get between you and your art, least of all yourself.

Podcast "FRANK: Vol. 1 – Boiling Point"


I really enjoyed this. It’s great to read this kind of honest appraisal of things. Thanks.
I’m always worried about posting this kind of stuff because (again) I’m worried what people will think of me, but they always seem to enjoy these posts the most. I think that might qualify as irony in this particular situation! I’m very glad you liked it
I think I’m the opposite. I had a step-father that was down right nasty to me (and his own kids, come to think of it), so I learned not to judge too much on what he said. That stuck with me too.
I like you.
Hahahaha Thank you
I’ve encountered various people who’ve been downright nasty to me too, but I always took it to heart. What can I say? I’m in a recovery process
But there is never a time for worrying about whether other people will like you or not. They will or they won’t.
I still worry about it. Hoping and wishing people do.
And then, when I get depressed? I go the other way and actively believe no one likes me or cares about me. Even people who have said and demonstrated otherwise.
I have moments like that. It’s possibly the single the most self-destructive thing we can do. And no one can change your mind about yourself except you. It has to come from within. Very difficult.
Once again you have chosen a random nail and hit it on the head. You too in boarding school. Ha, some of the experience lives with me still. But, its none of your business what other people think.
PS I like you too
and your writing.
This wasn’t intended as a compliment fishing expedition, but I appreciate the support nonetheless
And yes, boarding school. It stays with us forever, I think
I like you. But you’re right in that those aren’t the important things.
What you write is more important, how you write is important… And Then when you’re ready, HOW you present yourself, and your book matters too.
I think people love these posts BECAUSE they’re scary to write. They’re you being honest, and it’s something that resonates with people. We like to know that other people out there are just as scared as we are.
I’m one of those people who talks a big game in her comfort zone, and can be brash and opinionated at times… But deep down, I want people to like me. Sometimes I think the only reason I feel confident in being myself is because I don’t think anyone’s really watching.
The old adage, ‘Dance like no one’s looking’? Write like you want to read, and talk like only your friends are listening, and sing in the shower. Maybe the rest will follow?
Hahahahaha “Write like you want to read and talk like only your friends are listening.” Nice! I like you too
This was a hard lesson for me to learn as well. One day I decided, everyone has an opinion and I have the right to ignore any opinion – sure, we all want to be liked but that desire should never lead us to sacrifice ourselves and no one worth having as a friend would ever ask us to make that type of sacrifice. So, when someone say: Do this and I’ll be your friend or Act this way in order to be my friend – my response is – No thanks, you’ve already proven you can’t be a friend and then move on without giving it another thought.
Okay, I rambled – but somehow, because we are friends I believe, you will understand the ramble
Kristen had a post last week that hits on this thought. Dropping you a link -> http://warriorwriters.wordpress.com/2012/05/30/learning-to-drop-the-donkey-is-perfectionism-killing-your-career/
Glad to have you as a friend, Mhairi and um, I actually enjoy your “occasional obnoxiousness”
Well, that’s a relief
Thanks for the link, I’ll check it out
I hear ya. I have “like me, like me” syndrome too. After my book came out, I learned just how much I was still yearning for everybody’s approval. I know you can’t please everyone, and I’m working on getting that through my head, but my skin hadn’t fully thickened yet. I think artistic/creative people are naturally more sensitive to the world around them (including what other people think) so it’s a challenge.
I find it paralyses me creatively, too, when I’m focussed on what other people are going to think of my stuff, rather than the writing of the stuff. It’s one of those things that has to come from within. No matter how much people tell you you’re a great writer (and there will always be people who don’t think you’re a great writer) you really have to make the decision about the quality of your writing yourself. I’ve taken ages to get to the point where I can focus on the writing rather than what other people may or may not think of it.
[...] can’t dwell on it any more. I will be me and they will be them. As I said in a previous post, people don’t have to like you. You don’t have to like them, either. It’s a free will thing.That said, as far as [...]